Wednesday, February 10, 2010

10-Response to: Follow-Up Observations Highlight Uncertainties in Exoplanet Research

This article was very interesting considering the last article that I found for my blog. The last article that I responded to was all about newly discovered exoplanets with earth-like masses. After reading this article, however, I am reminded that many of these newly discovered planets may not actually exist due to this flaw in the radial velocity method. The radial velocity method is also the most used if not the only method with which exoplanets are discovered, which means that many of the 400 exoplanets which are not actually visable to a telescope may not actually be there. One thing I really wish that this article had expounded upon a bit more was the Europen Space Agency's Gaia project. I have never heard about this project before reading about it in this article and it sounds like it may be a very big step forward in the technology used for discovering exoplanets, however I really don't know what it is. This is possibly something that I will search for when choosing my next article.

10-Notes on: Follow-Up Observations Highlight Uncertainties in Exoplanet Research

-Very few exoplanets have actually been seen
-More than 400 proposed exoplanets currently
-More than 60 proposed exoplanets have been retracted upon further research
-Many times further research turns up brown dwarves or other stars instead of exoplanets
-HD 136118 b was thought to have a mass 12 times that of jupiter but was discovered to have 42 times the mass of jupiter (13 times the mass of jupiter or more is a brown dwarf or something bigger)
-HD 33636 b was thought to have 7.7 times the mass of jupiter but was found to have 142 times the mass of jupiter
-Radial velocity method can not account for the shape or direction of the orbit of the proposed exoplanet which messes up the math involved, can only come up with a lower end estimate
-Radial velocity method will never be able to overcome this fault because it just doesn't work
-Cross checking with a high powered telescope can reveal of the radial velocity calculations are correct or not, but only for stars that are near enough to us and there are precious few telescopes of this magnitude
-European space agency's "Gaia" may be able to fill in the blanks for some of these proposed exoplanets, expected to launch in 2012.