Monday, December 21, 2009

Response to: Exoplanet claim bites the dust

I found this article to be very interesting. Being at least a little bit knowledgeable in the field of astronomy I have known about the astrometry method for some time, however I have not known that it apparently gives some inaccurate findings. I am somewhat critical of the observations which were made to denounce the findings though, because they needed to modify the telescope to be able to view the infrared light that the star was emitting. Did they test their newly modified telescope by looking for already well known exoplanets? If they did not then how do we know if their telescope even functioned properly? If the claims against the astrometry are true, however, this could mean that a lot of previously discovered exoplanets may very well not be there, considering how long the astrometry method has been around. I would very much like to see some numbers on how many exoplanets have actually been discovered using the astrometry method, because their existence may be false.

Notes on: Exoplanet calim bites the dust

-A planet that was thought to have orbited a star called VB10 about 6 parces from Earth and be about 6 times as massive as Jupiter's existence has been apparently disproved.
-Planet was originally discovered using a method known as astrometry, which measures that wobble of a star to see if outside gravitational forces are working on it
-Radial velocity method, which measures gravitational influences on different rays of light, was used to disprove the claim
-Modification to the telescope used was needed to be able to view infrared rays for radial velocity method
-Astrometry's accuracy is distorted by the Earth's atmosphere
-New projects in the near future may allow for astrometry method to be used outside of Earth's atmosphere